xTool P2S vs xTool S1 40W
Verdict
On our scores the xTool P2S comes out ahead, 82 to 78. The xTool P2S is a 55 W co2 laser with a 600 × 308 mm work area; the xTool S1 40W is a 40 W diode laser with 498 × 319 mm. The xTool S1 40W costs about $1,300 less at list price.
The xTool P2S is best for
Makers and small businesses who want a real CO2 cutter for wood and acrylic products without building a dedicated laser room.The xTool S1 40W is best for
Hobbyists and small sellers who want a powerful diode cutter for wood and dark acrylic that is safe to run in a shared space.Specs and scores side by side
| xTool P2S | xTool S1 40W | |
|---|---|---|
| Laser type | CO2 laser | Diode laser |
| Form | Enclosed | Enclosed |
| Optical power | 55 W | 40 W |
| Work area | 600 × 308 mm | 498 × 319 mm |
| Max speed | 600 mm/s | 600 mm/s |
| Air assist | Built in | Included |
| Camera | Yes | No |
| Autofocus | Yes | Yes |
| Safety | Enclosed with automatic lid lock, AI flame detection and emergency stop; sold as a Class 1 version (lid and baseplate interlocks) and a Class 4 version | Class 1 enclosure with lid-open stop, 5-direction flame detection, emergency stop and key lock; becomes Class 4 with the Class 4 riser base and conveyor |
| Weight | 45 kg | 20 kg |
| Price | $2,999 | $1,699 |
| Overall score | 82 | 78 |
| Power score | 82 | 80 |
| Speed score | 66 | 66 |
| Ease score | 88 | 84 |
| Safety score | 85 | 90 |
| Value score | 80 | 76 |
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, the xTool P2S or the xTool S1 40W?
On our scores the xTool P2S comes out ahead, 82 to 78. The xTool P2S is a 55 W co2 laser with a 600 × 308 mm work area; the xTool S1 40W is a 40 W diode laser with 498 × 319 mm. The xTool S1 40W costs about $1,300 less at list price.
Which is cheaper, the xTool P2S or the xTool S1 40W?
At list price the xTool S1 40W ($1,699) costs less than the xTool P2S ($2,999).
How we rank: by our own scores for power, speed, ease of use, safety and value, from the maker's published specs and independent tests where they exist. Some links earn us a commission (for example TwoTrees, SainSmart, Gweike and Amazon). That never changes a score or the order of a list (disclosure).