AtomStack A70 Max vs xTool P2S
Verdict
On our scores the xTool P2S comes out ahead, 82 to 70. The AtomStack A70 Max is a 70 W diode laser with a 850 × 800 mm work area; the xTool P2S is a 55 W co2 laser with 600 × 308 mm. The AtomStack A70 Max costs about $1,360 less at list price.
The AtomStack A70 Max is best for
Makers and small shops who mainly cut thick wood and dark acrylic and have a garage or workshop with proper extraction.The xTool P2S is best for
Makers and small businesses who want a real CO2 cutter for wood and acrylic products without building a dedicated laser room.Specs and scores side by side
| AtomStack A70 Max | xTool P2S | |
|---|---|---|
| Laser type | Diode laser | CO2 laser |
| Form | Open frame | Enclosed |
| Optical power | 70 W | 55 W |
| Work area | 850 × 800 mm | 600 × 308 mm |
| Max speed | 400 mm/s (24,000 mm/min) | 600 mm/s |
| Air assist | Included | Built in |
| Camera | No | Yes |
| Autofocus | Yes | Yes |
| Safety | Open frame with an exposed Class 4 beam; flame alarm, emergency stop button and gyroscope tilt detection; enclosure sold separately | Enclosed with automatic lid lock, AI flame detection and emergency stop; sold as a Class 1 version (lid and baseplate interlocks) and a Class 4 version |
| Weight | 19 kg | 45 kg |
| Price | $1,639 | $2,999 |
| Overall score | 70 | 82 |
| Power score | 88 | 82 |
| Speed score | 60 | 66 |
| Ease score | 62 | 88 |
| Safety score | 38 | 85 |
| Value score | 68 | 80 |
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, the AtomStack A70 Max or the xTool P2S?
On our scores the xTool P2S comes out ahead, 82 to 70. The AtomStack A70 Max is a 70 W diode laser with a 850 × 800 mm work area; the xTool P2S is a 55 W co2 laser with 600 × 308 mm. The AtomStack A70 Max costs about $1,360 less at list price.
Which is cheaper, the AtomStack A70 Max or the xTool P2S?
At list price the AtomStack A70 Max ($1,639) costs less than the xTool P2S ($2,999).
How we rank: by our own scores for power, speed, ease of use, safety and value, from the maker's published specs and independent tests where they exist. Some links earn us a commission (for example TwoTrees, SainSmart, Gweike and Amazon). That never changes a score or the order of a list (disclosure).